The Canadian Encyclopedia — neutral, cited, updated
July 26, 2026Sources cited
Canadianwire.
Canada’s encyclopedia & explainer
HomeCulture & LifestyleFoodSicilian pizza
Culture & Lifestyle • Food

Sicilian pizza

Sicilian pizza is a style of pizza associated with Sicily, Italy, and also with a square, thick-crust pizza popular in the United States.

By Ethan Anderson| Reviewed by Olivia Bennett, Standards & Fact-Checking Lead| Updated July 26, 2026|2 min read| Fact-checked

Sicilian pizza is a style of pizza associated with Sicily, Italy, and also with a square, thick-crust pizza popular in the United States. In Sicily, the traditional form is often linked to sfincione, a rectangular, bread-like pizza that commonly uses tomatoes, onions, anchovies, and hard local cheese, while cheese may be omitted in some versions. In North America, “Sicilian pizza” usually means a thick, square pan pizza with a crisp bottom and airy interior.

Origins

Sicilian pizza originated in Sicily and was a common dish there by the mid-19th century. Traditional accounts identify sfincione as the older Sicilian form, especially associated with Palermo.

Traditional Sicilian style

The Sicilian version is usually thick-crusted and often rectangular, though round versions exist. It is commonly topped with tomato, onions, anchovies, herbs, and cheeses such as caciocavallo or toma, though some versions omit cheese.

American Sicilian pizza

In the United States, Sicilian pizza usually refers to a square or rectangular pan pizza with a thick crust, crisp bottom, and airy interior. It is commonly cut into square slices and is often made in a style similar to other American pan pizzas.

Relation to sfincione

Sfincione is widely described as the traditional Sicilian ancestor of Sicilian-style pizza. Some modern descriptions treat the American version as an adaptation of sfincione rather than a direct copy of the Sicilian original.

Key facts

  • Sicilian pizza can refer to both a Sicilian regional pizza and an Americanized square pan pizza.
  • Traditional Sicilian pizza is often associated with sfincione, a thick, bread-like style.
  • The American version is typically baked in a greased rectangular pan and cut into squares.
  • The crust is usually thicker than Neapolitan-style pizza and has a soft interior with a crisp base.
  • Traditional Sicilian toppings often include tomato, onion, anchovy, herbs, and local hard cheese.
🍁
Canadian context

Sicilian pizza is common in Canadian pizzerias, especially in Italian-Canadian communities and urban food scenes where North American-style square pan pizza is widely sold.

Frequently asked questions

What is Sicilian pizza?
It is a pizza style associated with Sicily and, in the United States, a thick square pan pizza with a soft, airy crust and crisp base.
Is Sicilian pizza always square?
No. The traditional Sicilian form is often rectangular, but sources note that it can also be round. The American version is usually square or rectangular.
What is sfincione?
Sfincione is the traditional Sicilian pizza often described as the ancestor of Sicilian-style pizza. It is a thick, bread-like pizza commonly linked to Palermo.
What toppings are traditional?
Traditional toppings often include tomatoes, onions, anchovies, herbs, and hard cheeses such as caciocavallo or toma.
How is American Sicilian pizza different from Neapolitan pizza?
American Sicilian pizza is much thicker, baked in a pan, and usually has a crisp bottom and airy crumb, unlike the thinner Neapolitan style.
Does Sicilian pizza always contain cheese?
No. Some traditional Sicilian versions include hard local cheeses, while other versions are made without cheese.

References

  1. Wikipediahttps://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Sicilian_pizza
    Supports: General description, traditional and U.S. style characteristics, toppings, and historical overview.
  2. PizzaBlabhttps://www.pizzablab.com/the-encyclopizza/sicilian-pizza/
    Supports: Sfincione connection, pan-baked rectangular style, thick crust, and American adaptation claims.
  3. Allrecipeshttps://www.allrecipes.com/what-is-sicilian-style-pizza-8642252
    Supports: Origins in Sicily, thick spongy dough, deep square-pan preparation, and historical context.
  4. Pizza Todayhttps://www.pizzatoday.com/news/knead-to-know-sicilian-style-pizza/146019/
    Supports: Current usage of the term for thick-crust rectangular pan pizza and relation to sfincione.